Everything We Were Not Supposed to Be

The music from the reception hall drifted up through the ventilation shafts and dissolved somewhere above the rooftop pool, thin and far away, like a radio left on in another room. Yetunde had been standing at the edge of the terrace for six minutes — she had counted — watching the harbor lights smear themselves across the dark water below Cape Town, when she heard the door behind her open and then, unmistakably, close.

“I wondered how long before one of us escaped,” Cosimo said.

“I was here first.”

“I noticed.” He stopped a few feet behind her, not quite beside her. “Your seat was empty during the toast. Amara’s mother kept looking at it.”

“Amara’s mother has been looking at me like I’m a problem she hasn’t solved since 2019.” Yetunde finally turned. Cosimo Serra was still in his jacket, which surprised her — she’d half-expected him to have shed it the moment he cleared the door, the way he always shed the formal version of himself the second he thought no one important was watching. But here he was, jacket on, collar button still fastened, hands in his pockets with that particular stillness that she had spent fourteen months learning not to read too carefully. “Why are you up here?”

“Same reason you are, I imagine.”

“I needed air.”

“So did I.”

She turned back to the harbor.

The rooftop pool ran the length of the terrace, lit from beneath so that the water glowed a pale, unearthly blue against the Cape Town night. On three sides, the city rose and fell in terraces of light — the mountain dark and enormous behind it all, its flat summit holding up the sky. On the fourth side, the harbor. Container ships moored far out, their running lights slow and patient. Closer in, the waterfront glittered and moved. The wind off the Atlantic came in low and salt-edged, and Yetunde felt it lift the hem of her dress, the coral silk she had chosen three weeks ago when attending this wedding had still felt like a manageable professional obligation rather than the specific kind of personal test it had turned out to be.

Because Cosimo was here. Of course he was here. He was always, in every room that mattered, here.

She heard him move to the railing two feet to her left. Not close enough to be pointed. Not far enough to be a message. She had become, over fourteen months of working in adjacent roles at the same logistics firm, fluent in the precise geometry of Cosimo Serra’s distances. Two feet meant he was leaving the next move to her. She had always found that both generous and infuriating.

“Did you know they’d seat us at the same table?” he asked.

“No.”

“I didn’t either.” A pause. “I would have told you.”

She believed him. That was the part she could never quite work around — she believed almost everything Cosimo said, which was a liability she had catalogued and chosen, repeatedly, to ignore.

From Cosimo’s side of the railing, the harbor looked the same and nothing like what he was seeing. He was watching Yetunde’s reflection in the dark water of the pool beside them — the coral dress, the clean line of her shoulders, the way she held herself at the edge of things as though she was deciding, always deciding, whether to step back or forward. He had seen her in boardrooms and airport lounges and once, memorably, in a glass-walled conference room in Johannesburg at eleven at night when a freight contract had gone sideways and everyone else had gone home. She had stayed. He had stayed. They had fixed it. And afterward, in the elevator down, she had said something small and funny about the vending machine on the fourth floor, and he had laughed, and the doors had opened, and they had both walked out into their separate lives as if none of it had a charge to it. As if proximity were neutral. As if he hadn’t thought about that elevator for the next three weeks.

He was her firm’s regional counterpart. She was the client-side lead on two of his accounts. There were policies — not written ones, but the kind that lived in the architecture of professional relationships and did not require documentation to carry real weight. He understood them. He had always understood them. What he had not anticipated, when he’d accepted Amara’s wedding invitation eight months ago, was that Yetunde would be in the wedding party. Or that the wedding would be in Cape Town, in a hotel with a rooftop pool that seemed designed specifically to make it difficult to be sensible.

“How long are you staying?” she asked.

“I fly Monday morning. You?”

“Sunday evening.”

So one more day. He did the arithmetic without meaning to.

Yetunde watched a ferry cross the harbor far below, its wake spreading and then erasing itself against the dark. She was aware of every inch of the two feet between them. She was aware of the music still filtering up from somewhere beneath their feet — something slow now, a song she didn’t know — and of the way the pool light caught the edge of Cosimo’s jaw when he turned his face slightly toward her. She had a rule about noticing things like that. The rule was: don’t. She had broken it approximately four hundred times in fourteen months and was, at this particular moment, breaking it again.

The thing about forbidden things, she had learned, was that they were rarely forbidden because they were wrong. They were forbidden because they were complicated, because they sat at the intersection of everything you’d built and everything you wanted, and the cost of wanting them was that you had to keep choosing, every day, not to reach.

“Yetunde.”

She didn’t look at him. “Don’t.”

“I haven’t said anything.”

“You were about to.”

A long pause. The wind moved between them.

“Maybe,” he said.

From where Cosimo stood, her profile was very still. He knew she wasn’t indifferent — he had known that for a long time, the way you know things you’re not supposed to act on, that live in the peripheral vision of your professional life and refuse to resolve into something you can simply set aside. He knew it from the way she’d handed him a coffee in Johannesburg without asking how he took it and gotten it exactly right. He knew it from the way she’d argued with him in the Cape Town office three months ago about a shipping timeline — sharp and precise and a little exhilarated, the way people get when they’re fighting with someone they respect too much to be careful around. He knew it from the fact that she was still standing here, at the edge of this terrace, when she could have gone back inside the moment she’d heard the door.

She hadn’t gone back inside.

Neither had he.

“I’ve been thinking,” Cosimo said, carefully, “about the Mombasa contract.”

Yetunde exhaled a short, surprised sound that was almost a laugh. “At Amara’s wedding.”

“The Mombasa contract ends in March.” He said it simply, without emphasis, but she understood the shape of what he meant immediately and completely, because she had been thinking it too, in the private margins of her working days, in the space between what was permitted and what she wanted. The Mombasa contract was the last account that put them on the same professional footing. When it closed, the specific configuration that made this complicated — that made them counterparts rather than simply two people — would change. He wasn’t making a move. He was naming a fact. He was leaving the geometry up to her, the way he always did.

She turned to look at him then. Full on, which she almost never did — she had learned to manage her exposure to the direct version of Cosimo Serra, the one that existed when he wasn’t performing competence at a conference table but simply standing somewhere, present and unhurried, looking back. He was looking back now. The pool light between them made the water glow, made the air above it shimmer faintly, and the harbor behind him was vast and patient and indifferent to both of them.

“March,” she said.

“March,” he confirmed.

Neither of them said anything else. The music below had shifted again — something with a piano now, a melody that climbed and didn’t quite resolve. The wind came in off the Atlantic and moved through the space between them, and Yetunde felt, with a clarity that was almost physical, the exact weight of everything they had not said across fourteen months, all of it present and accounted for in the six feet of warm Cape Town air between them. She thought about Johannesburg. She thought about the elevator. She thought about the way he had laughed — genuinely, without calculation — at something small and ordinary, and how that laugh had rearranged something in her that she’d spent the subsequent months trying to rearrange back.

She took one step sideways. Toward him. Not reaching, not declaring — just closing one foot of the two feet that had existed between them since he’d walked through the door.

Cosimo didn’t move. He didn’t need to. He simply remained where he was, steady and unhurried, and let the distance be what it now was.

Below them, the harbor held its lights on the water. The mountain held the sky. The music played on, muffled and sweet, belonging to someone else’s night. And on the rooftop, two people who had been careful for a very long time stood one foot apart in the blue glow of the pool, watching the same stretch of dark water, their shoulders almost — almost — touching.

0
Get new stories in this category

About the Author

Clara Vance

Clara Vance — a former corporate strategist, expert in the tension that builds between two desks. Her hobby? Morning coffee chats in the office where she collects ideas for her stories.
— Clara Vance

Full author profile

Categories: ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Article